Perspectives16 November 20267 min read

What if innovation began by depriving yourself of resources?

By Cyrille Lecroq R&DInnovationPrototyping

When you start an R&D project, you generally try to gather the best possible conditions for success.

A sufficient budget, suitable equipment, the right skills, the most powerful technologies…

That’s perfectly logical. After all, why make life difficult when you have the means to do things properly?

Yet, over the years, I’ve developed a habit that may seem a little paradoxical: I systematically try to impose frugality constraints on myself in my R&D projects.

Not out of an obsession with savings, nor because I believe a cheap solution would necessarily be better.

But because I’ve found that a lack of resources can sometimes become a remarkable driver of creativity.

And above all, because it forces us off the paths we would naturally have taken.

The comfort of well-marked paths #

Faced with a technical problem, we never truly start from scratch.

We have our experience, our knowledge, our habits, the technologies we master and those we can easily access.

All of this is a considerable asset.

But it also shapes the way we approach problems.

When we look for a solution, we naturally tend to turn to what we already know. To proven architectures, available components, methods we know work.

And there’s nothing wrong with that.

Taking a well-marked path is reassuring. It reduces uncertainty, keeps deadlines under control and limits risks.

In many situations, it’s exactly what should be done.

But in R&D, that safety can also become a limit.

Because by favouring the solutions we already know exist, how many others do we set aside without even having considered them?

It isn’t necessarily a lack of imagination.

It’s simply human.

Why set off to explore an unknown forest when a perfectly maintained road already takes us to our destination?

When a constraint closes one door… and opens others #

A constraint changes the way we approach a problem.

When a technology becomes inaccessible, a component unavailable, or a budget no longer allows the usual solution, we’re forced to reconsider our options.

And sometimes, to go back to a much more fundamental question:

What am I really trying to obtain?

Not which component to use, which software to develop or which technology to integrate.

But which function must be ensured, which phenomenon must be mastered, which result must be achieved.

This distinction may seem obvious. Yet it considerably changes the space of possible solutions.

A function we had spontaneously entrusted to electronics can sometimes be ensured by mechanics.

A problem we thought we’d solve with software can sometimes disappear by modifying the system’s architecture.

A solution requiring several components can sometimes be obtained by exploiting the properties of a single one differently.

These aren’t general rules, and no technical discipline is intrinsically preferable to another.

The point is elsewhere: the constraint pushes us to question the means before questioning the objective.

It invites us to explore possibilities that our experience, paradoxically, might have led us to ignore.

An experience that changed the way I approach R&D #

During lockdown, I set out to develop an electronic stethoscope: the SKOP.

I was funding this R&D out of my own pocket, but the main obstacle wasn’t financial.

It was access to hardware.

Supply lead times made it hard to obtain certain electronic components. And I couldn’t simply wait several weeks every time I needed to experiment with a new solution.

I essentially had two 3D printers, a few resistors, jack connectors and electret microphones.

Not exactly the ideal equipment to develop the digital stethoscope I would probably have designed in other circumstances.

So I had to look elsewhere.

Rather than entrusting all of the sound processing to electronics and digital technology, I explored the possibilities offered by acoustics itself.

By combining a membrane with a conical duct coiled on itself, in a geometry reminiscent of a cochlea, I was able to exploit the acoustic properties of the device to act on the sound even before it was picked up by the microphone.

This approach gave rise to an architecture I probably wouldn’t have considered if I’d had immediate access to all the equipment I wanted.

It isn’t so much this project’s result that interests me here.

It’s what led me to explore it.

Had I had all the resources I needed, I would most likely have followed a much more conventional path.

And I might have missed this possibility.

Why wait until resources run short? #

This experience reinforced a conviction I now deliberately apply in my R&D work.

Even when resources are available, I try to start with the minimum.

I ask myself what could be achieved with fewer components, less energy, less computing power, less equipment or a deliberately restricted budget.

Not to obtain the cheapest solution at all costs.

But to prevent the abundance of available resources from determining too quickly how I’m going to solve the problem.

It’s a form of constraint I impose on myself to provoke exploration.

By removing certain possibilities, I force myself to seek out others.

This doesn’t mean the solutions found will necessarily be better.

Some avenues turn out to be impractical. Others take too much time, introduce new difficulties, or simply don’t reach the expected performance.

And it sometimes happens that, after several experiments, the conventional solution remains the most relevant.

But at least that choice then rests on a broader exploration.

Because the goal isn’t to succeed with less at all costs.

The goal is to discover what we might never have looked for had we had more.

Frugality is not an end in itself #

It would obviously be absurd to claim that a lack of resources systematically fosters innovation.

Some research requires considerable investment, cutting-edge equipment and years of work.

And excessive constraints can simply prevent a project from succeeding.

You also have to beware of false economies.

Spending weeks developing an alternative solution to avoid buying an inexpensive component can perfectly well turn out to be counterproductive.

Time, too, is a resource.

That’s why I consider frugality a constraint for exploration, not a permanent obligation to cut costs.

You can start by looking for how to do it with very little, then decide to invest more when it becomes necessary.

You can experiment with an unusual architecture, observe its limits and finally settle on a proven solution.

There’s no failure in that.

Frugality isn’t meant to replace technical judgement. On the contrary, it should enrich it.

And above all, the constraints we impose during exploration must never lead to sacrificing the safety, reliability or performance requirements of the final product.

Rediscovering the pleasure of exploring #

I think there’s another, more personal reason for my attachment to this approach.

I love exploring.

I love finding myself in front of a problem whose solution I don’t immediately know, trying improbable things, discovering that an old physical principle can answer a very current problem.

And sometimes, rediscovering simple solutions that the availability of more sophisticated technologies had made us forget.

Of course, exploration carries a risk.

That of spending time on an idea that will lead nowhere.

That of being wrong, starting over, having to finally return to the starting point.

But that’s also what makes it exciting.

We now have access to an extraordinary amount of knowledge, tools and technologies. It’s an immense opportunity for R&D.

And yet, I’m not sure that having ever more resources systematically pushes us to explore more.

Sometimes, I even have the impression that it’s the opposite.

So, from time to time, I prefer to deliberately deprive myself of a few possibilities.

Not to make the work harder than it should be.

Simply to see what happens when you can no longer take the usual path.

Because beyond results, performance and industrial objectives, R&D also remains, for me, this wonderful opportunity to discover or rediscover spaces of creativity I would never have imagined.